Which is better Lump Charcoal or Briquettes?

Which is better Lump Charcoal or Briquettes?

Lump Charcoal vs Briquettes – When it comes to charcoal, there is only one option: lump or briquettes. In this guide, we contrast the advantages and disadvantages of each. We discuss when to use one or the other, as well as the benefits of switching between the two at the appropriate times.

Charcoal has more potential energy than raw wood because of its high carbon content: it can provide cooking heat that burns hotter, more steadily, and cleaner than dried wood.

To say that a fire burns cleaner simply means that it is free of eye-watering, sneeze-inducing chemicals that go up in smoke. That is one of the advantages of using charcoal instead of dried wood.

Lump vs Briquettes Key Takeaways

  • Lump – Is made entirely of natural carbonized wood, burns hotter but faster, and has an irregular shape that can result in inconsistent burns. It enhances the flavor of food with smoke.
  • Briquettes are pressed sawdust that has been carbonized; they often contain fillers and binders, burn cooler but for a longer period of time, and burn consistently due to their uniform shape. It imparts a mild smoky flavor to food.
  • Can be used in most grills and smokers.
  • Lump-wood is best for high-heat searing and grilling, as well as adding the most flavor.
  • Briquettes are preferable for controlled, low and slow smoking – except in kamado style grills, which require lump.

What is Lump Charcoal?

Lump is the most basic form of charcoal and is essentially wood that has been partially burned down to basics, then carbonized until all that is left is carbon.

It is burned in a low-oxygen silo to take away sap, moisture, and naturally occurring methane, hydrogen, and a variety of other chemicals. The process is known as charring, and charcoal is sometimes sold as char wood.

It can be considered a form of recycling because it is mostly made up of byproducts of coppicing and scrap wood from mills and wood businesses, rather than new trees. It typically burns at 1400°F (760°C) or higher, a much higher temperature than briquettes can achieve.

Pros and Cons of Lump Charcoal

Lump charcoal has some pros and cons when the users use it in some ways. Those following pros and cons are:

  1. Pros

  • Because it burns hot, it must be closely monitored; especially if you intend to use it for smoking, which necessitates a low, steady, and long-lasting flame.
  • It is designed to burn for an hour, making it ideal for a quick grilling session.
  • It smells fantastic.
  • Produces a lot of smoke flavor
  1. Cons

  • Not every piece has been completely carbonized.
  • Larger pieces still have cellulose and lignin, which are two of the three main wood components.
  • It burns quickly, necessitating the addition of more over the course of a long cooking session. You’ll be purchasing a lot of bags.
  • Unevenly sized pieces can range from a half to 4 inches in length, resulting in unpredictable cooking times.
  • Cooking times that are unpredictable
  • Even if you find a brand you like, the results are inconsistent from bag to bag.
  • Burns at varying temperatures
  • More expensive than briquettes
  • It easily breaks down into small, useless bits and dust.
  • Reduces airflow, which results in a slow-burning fire.

Lighting That Fire

There is self-lighting charcoal, but you should avoid it – as well as using lighting fluid – because the chemical smell of the fuel-soaked lumps will affect the flavor of your food. Allowing time for lighting fluid to burn off may help, but it will never completely solve the problem.

As a result, buy only all-natural lump-wood charcoal with no added chemicals, and start the fire with a natural firelighter, such as wood wool or organic all-natural starter cubes.

What is Briquette?

Briquettes are typically made of compressed sawdust that has been converted into carbon and is uniform in shape. They are light, uniform, and reasonably priced.

Historically, additives were mixed into sawdust before being pressed into molds. Briquettes are the charcoal equivalent of a chicken patty. They typically burn at temperatures ranging from 800 to 1000°F.

Pros and Cons of Briquettes

Briquettes also have pros and cons, those are:

  1. Pros

  • They have the design to burn longer and at a lower temperature, making them ideal for smoking.
  • When using the snake or domino method, their uniform shape makes them easier to arrange.
  • Lightweight, inexpensive, and convenient
  1. Cons

  • Potential allergens and additives
  • It takes more time to light.
  • Because there is less wood to burn, there is more ash.

Identifying Common Ground of Lump and Briquette

Lump as well as briquettes, because:

  • It comes from from trees
  • Are terminated
  • It has the potential to self-ignite.
  • It is possible to be chemical-free.

What is the Difference of Lump Charcoal and Briquettes Charcoal?

Let’s take a look at some of the characteristics that distinguish them and dispel a few myths along the way:

  1. The difference during use

There are differences in how the two types of coal burn, and thus differences in how we should use them. However, not everything you hear is always true.

  • Fueled by air

The conventional wisdom holds that lump is best for hot and fast grilling, whereas briquettes are best for low and slow. Fire, on the other hand, is fed by air, or oxygen.

A lump charcoal fire with dust and bits obstructing airflow can burn low and slow, similar to a briquette fire. You can also intentionally reduce the airflow in your barbecue by controlling the vents.

  • Time and speed

To design the briquettes, it will burn for hours, making them ideal for snake smoking and other methods of smoking. They’re ideal for low and slow cooking. Briquettes are the grill’s equivalent of a slow cooker. Put the ingredients together, go to work, and come home to a delicious meal.

Lump is intended to burn hot and fast for a short period of time, typically an hour. This is excellent for direct grilling and searing. However, this does not preclude their use in indirect heat applications. The difference is effort: you’ll need to add more lump charcoal, whereas the briquettes will cruise along without your intervention.

  • Grill types

People used to know briquette more than lump because of their ease of use, low cost, and convenience. However, because kamado smokers don’t have much space for ash collection, they can easily become overwhelmed by briquette fallout, with the increased amount of ash produced blocking airflow through the charcoal grate in the firebox.

This can result in unwelcome temperature drops or even the fire going out! Overall, depending on the parameters and knowledge of how to use the fuel type correctly in your specific smoker or grill, either can work for most grill or smoker needs. People with kamados, on the other hand, will typically use lump charcoal.

  1. The location and environment

High altitude grillers face the challenge of keeping a fire going because the air is depleted of oxygen, moisture, and pressure.

Briquettes may work better in these high altitude and low oxygen environments because the very thin air makes cooking a low and slow process, even if that is not what you are aiming for.

In sum, the lump charcoal and briquette charcoal will be the best depends on the purpose of use and their benefits. The users can use lump charcoal vs briquette effectively if they understand both functions. Looking for best lump charcoal and briquette charcoal supplier? Nusagro is the best option!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


If you have any questions about our products, we would love to hear from you. Please Call Us Today.


Jalan Tugu Raya No. 04, Tugu, Kecamatan Cimanggis, Kota Depok - Indonesia

+62 851-7441-0096